Within thirty years of John Wesley's preaching, Methodism arrived here. In 1817, the Rev. Ira Eddy, riding circuit, came to this area and preached a revival on the banks of the Allegheny below Warren at what is now Starbrick. An active class, starting with the Meads and the Reeses, lived, prayed, and worked there until 1933, when the Class of seventy decided to move to Warren and built next to the central school. This Church, the first brick building in Warren, was located where now [c. 1977] is the parking lot next to the Boro building. In 1836, the Church was incorporated as the First Methodist Church at Warren Station, and the charter solemnly stated that male members over 21 years of age had a voice.

 

Methodism in Warren was active and growing for fifty years; therefore, in 1885, a new church was built at the exact location. This Church served the congregation until 1927, when our present Church was built at Second and Market Streets, and the old Church was sold to the Evangelicals of Warren.

 

Some of us remember the old Church. The sanctuary was on the second floor, with a balcony sweeping to the chancel on either side. The architecture, distinguished in its day, was theatrically Victorian Gothic, with opera seats instead of pews, a centered pulpit raised from the communion table in front, and the choir and organ furnishing a backdrop to all. When a significant Sunday School addition was built in 1912 at the rear of the Church, there was a complete and active plant for First Church.

 

Within a few years of the old Church's building, the membership had grown so large and Warren's East Side had become so developed that many members across the Creek organized a class. In 1893, Grace Methodist Church was organized with 104 members, having previously left behind a membership of 770 at First Church.

 

It is said that in the early 1920s, the Official Board faced the problem of rebuilding or replacing the old church organ. At a meeting, Jerry Crary voiced the opinion that a new organ in an old church was hardly appropriate. He announced that the L.F. Watson homestead at the corner of Second and Market Streets was committed to him on behalf of the Church. With new property available, the Board promptly took action toward building a new church.

 

Charles W. Bolton & Son of Philadelphia was engaged as an architect.

 

In 1925, plans for the new Church were presented and approved. Avoiding Victorian, Romanesque, and modern design, the architect offered a purely 13th-century Gothic church, with a 15th-century chapel added. Nothing so engenders an atmosphere of worship in a community as this traditional architecture, and we have the Building Committee of 1925 to thank for its choice. It would have pleased John Wesley to know that his Methodists in Warren returned to the church beauty in which he was reared and carried the spiritual enthusiasm he had to preach in the open fields. The only sad note in the church design was for some faithful who were profoundly unhappy about moving the preacher from a front-and-center pulpit to a side pulpit and a side lectern. But they later came to worship and looked aside at the preacher without loss of devotion.

 

As is fitting in a Gothic church, our sanctuary is filled with religious art. The sanctuary window is of Christ; the west window is of Moses and the Old Testament; the magnificent transept window is of the Apostles; the rose window over the chapel entrance is of the Lamb of God. The aisle windows portray Christ's miracles and parables.

 

The lovely south window in the Chapel honors the Virgin Mary, and the side windows depict the great founders of the Church -- Tyndale, Luther, Wesley, and Asbury.

 

The windows in the chapel corridor and throughout the church school display biblical mottoes. Attention is mainly called to the window just inside the chapel entrance, which notes, as one enters the Church, that "I will lay me down in peace, and sleep."

 

The statue of Jesus is particularly appealing over the entrance, welcoming his believers into worship.

 

Our fathers built better than they realized. As a result, for nearly 100 years, our house of worship has been a center of devotion and Christian Service in the community and throughout the world.

 

The building was dedicated at the Easter service in 1927 by our Bishop, Francis J. McConnell. Its twenty-fifth year was celebrated by our Bishop, Lloyd C. Wicke. Its fiftieth year, at its Palm Sunday service on April 3, 1977, will be [was] celebrated by a re-consecration to the Faith by Bishop Roy C. Nichols.

 

[Note: In 2002, we celebrated the 75th anniversary of the Church with Bishop Hae Jong Kim and district superintendent Robert Higginbotham.]

 

But what has happened, and what has come from our Church in this half-century?

 

In the first place, and of less importance than the Service that has marked our congregation, is the maintenance of the physical plant. Our original heating plant was fired with oil, as a buried tank car to the north of the Church testified. Later, coal was used, with an under-floor stoker located in the coal room beneath the rear courtyard. Since then, gas has been used, and the janitor has been relieved of his duties to perform his proper functions.

 

After twenty years, it was found that the Church's stone walls had been shoddily pointed, and the whole Church was re-mortared. Unfortunately, the Church's cast stone trim would not withstand the weathering, and despite repeated coating with paraffin paint, it continued to deteriorate. As a result, in 1976, all the copings had to be covered with lead-clad copper flashing, and the rest of the cast stone was recovered.

 

The electrical wiring was replaced entirely so that our present lighting could be used safely.

 

The entire heating control system has been rebuilt to ensure the congregation and Church School classes are comfortable. The church offering is not entirely devoted to the comfort of our people; it is remembered that a Church is an institution to comfort the afflicted and to afflict the comfortable.

 

Our beautiful stained glass windows have been protected by Lexan sheeting, which will also affect heat savings in the Church. [Of course, experts often change their minds--there are now plate glass protective panes...]

 

It should be noted that in 1948, our own Rev. Stephen T. Crary dedicated a World War II Memorial Altar in the Chapel, which lists the honored names of those who served their country. This altar was designed by Marion Sanford, recently of Warren, who has gained fame as a sculptor.

 

This Church is but a building. Where have we served the Church, and who has served us? From our Church have gone as ministers Bruce A. S. Wright, Morgan P. Noyes, Adolph P. Weaver, Stephen T. Crary, Frank C. Marlett, Jack MacDonald, Johan Stohl, and Keith Rieder. From our, Church have gone as missionaries Anna Samuelson Schreiber to Angola, Pearl Lund to Korea, Dorcas Hall to India, Martha McConnell, Jennie Smith, and Pauline Pittman. From our Church, Helen Noyes, Ethel M. Olson, Margaret Niederlander Hulslander, and Charles R. Eaton have gone into Christian social work. These have justified our Church in its Faith.

 

We have been served and ministered by:

 

Charles T. Greer............................1923-1932

 

Clarence E. Allen...........................1932-1936

 

Paul Selz, Asst...............................1932-1936

 

W. E. Bartlett..............................1936-1938

 

Thomas E. Colley............................1938-1943

 

L.G. Wayne Furman...........................1943-1950

 

Arthur B. R. Colley.........................1950-1956

 

A. Culmer Schultz...........................1956-1962

 

James G. Cousins............................1962-1968

 

Sherman Epler, Asst.         1962-1968

 

Adolph P. Weaver............................1968-1970

 

Elmer H. Reamer, Asst.       1968-1970

 

Jack E. Spencer.............................1970-1977

 

David L. Morse, Asst.        1971-1973

 

Glen Irvin, Asst.            1973-1975

 

James W. Kramer, Asst.       1975-1977

 

Harold Ray Kelly...........................1977-1980

 

Delbert E. Jolley Associate  1978-1992

 

Donald Everett Bloomster...................1980-1985

 

Harry Donald Lash..........................1985-1989

 

James Paul Ciampa..........................1989-1995

 

Peter Illyan Elencovf        1993-1994

 

Kenneth Anderson McGowan, Jr...............1995-1998

 

William John Starr.........................1998-2009

 

William Rue Beatty Associate 2002--2008

 

Jeffrey D. Sterling........................2009- 2014

 

Mark E. Hecht .............................. 2014 - Present 

 

Jon M. Swart, Parish Assoc. 2014 - 2017

                         Associate Minister 2025 - Present

​

First Methodist Church of Warren has consistently been recognized for its structure, outreach, and Service. World Service, Conference agencies, and missionary support have been at the heart of our financial program. Additionally, Christian outreach to the community has been a consistent pattern of our organization and its membership.

 

In recent years, our Church has been instrumental in the organization and provision of services for persons of special need carrying financial and leadership responsibilities for the Zodiac Coffee House -- a ministry to Edinboro Off-Campus Students, Community Concern House -- a residence for released patients of the State Hospital, Street Ministry to Youth through Churches United in Ministry, the establishment of the Warren County Jail Advisory Committee. We are strongly ecumenical in spirit and share fully in providing resources, leadership, and facilities for the programming of the Warren County Ministerial Association.

 

People enter our Church, worship, study, learn, and enjoy fellowship; they depart from the building having felt God's presence and being equipped for Service in the world.

 

Our history has been a beacon to the future. We are a people God calls to serve Him and our neighbors worldwide. The ministry and services our Church will render will continue the endless line of splendor that began within thirty years of John Wesley's preaching. What a privilege to be part of this movement of God in History.

 

In recent years, an elevator has been installed to give equal access to those unable to climb stairs. We continue to be a church that reaches out to the community, providing support for The Sharing Place, The Caring Place, Safe House, Jail Ministry, Habitat for Humanity, Healthy Communities, Healthy Youth, and Crary Home. We have made numerous improvements to the physical plant, including weatherizing the exterior, renovating and expanding the organ, repainting the walls, and retiling the floors in the sanctuary. The sound system in the sanctuary has been upgraded, and a new sound system was installed in Founders Hall. We continue a tape ministry and are expanding our web ministry...]
 
From Official Church Records
History: Methodist Episcopal - Erie Conference. The original Erie Circuit included portions of Warren County as early as 1806, with Reverend Robert Richford Roberts having preached in Warren that year. In 1812, Reverend Jacob Young, Presiding Elder of the Ohio District, held a Quarterly Meeting on the Conewango, a short distance above the village of Warren. Bishop McKendree was present at this meeting. In 1817, Reverend Ira Eddy organized a Methodist Class on the banks of the Allegheny two or three miles below Warren.

In 1830, Reverend James Gillmore was appointed to the Youngsville Circuit and found the small Class still worshipping below the village. An extensive revival that year increased the Class to about seventy members, and the meeting place was transferred to a Schoolhouse in the town. The Reverend Elkannah P. Steadman led in the building of the first Church on Third Avenue, a brick building, in 1833. In 1836, it became a Station appointment and was chartered. This Church was replaced by a larger structure on the same site, dedicated on September 19, 1886. In 1910, a Sunday school center was established, and in 1927, Reverend Charles T. Greer added a Sunday school center. The congregation then built and occupied the Gothic Church building, which features a sanctuary, a Chapel, and an educational unit. The membership in 1968 was 951. The membership on January 1, 2003, was 609.